Kaldor Centre Data Lab
The Kaldor Centre Data Lab publishes regularly updated data on Australia’s refugee status determination procedures. The data currently covers review at the Administrative Appeals Tribunal and Immigration Assessment Authority, as well as judicial review at the Federal Circuit and Family Court.
The data provides unprecedented insights into the decision-making patterns of individual tribunal members and judges, as well as into the way the system is operating as a whole.
Federal Circuit & Family Court
The Federal Circuit & Family Court data spans across over 6,700 cases from 1 January 2013 to 11 March 2021. The data was obtained using a programming script we developed that read and extracted the relevant data from published cases. For more details on the data collection process, see our .
The Federal Circuit & Family Court issuedÌýÌýin response to the publication of this data.
AAT & IAA
The data on the decision-making of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal and the Immigration Assessment Authority was obtained through Freedom of Information Requests.
The AAT dataset* includes 26,036 decisions made from 1 January 2015 to 18 May 2022.
The IAA dataset includes 10,157 decisions made from 1 May 2015 to 17 May 2022.
The Administrative Appeal Tribunal issuedÌýthis statementÌýin response to the publication of this data.Ìý
User note: Pivot Table
Each excel sheet uploaded in our database is accompanied by a PivotTable. A PivotTable is an interactive way to quickly summarise large amounts of data and can be used to obtain basic statistics on the various datapoints within each database. To use the PivotTable:
- Click anywhere in the table;
- In the PivotFields on the right handside of the screen select the data point you want displayed in the column, row and the relevant value.
Analysis
Explore
Publications
D. Ghezelbash, M. Bridle & K. Dorostkar,Ìý, AUSPUBLAW (20 Mar 2024)
D. Ghezelbash, K. Dorostkar & S. Walsh,ÌýÌý(2022) 45(3) ÁñÁ«¹ÙÍø Law Journal 1085
Submissions
- D. Ghezelbash, Submission to the Inquiry into the Administrative Review Tribunal Bill 2023 (ART Bill) and the Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional ProvisionsÌýNo.1) Bill 2023 (Consequential and Transitional Bill) Submission 11 (January 2024)
- D. Ghezelbash, K. Dorostkar and M. Bridle,ÌýSubmission to the Attorney-General’s Department responding to the Administrative Review Reform: Issues PaperÌý(May 2023)
- D. Ghezelbash, K. Dorostakar & S. Walsh,ÌýÌý(2021) (with the Refugee Council of Australia)
- D. Ghezelbash et al,ÌýÌý(June 2021) (with The Behavioural Insights Team and Macquarie University)
- This submission is referred to extensively in the Australian Law Reform Commission's report,ÌýÌý(Dec 2021), notably in connection with Recommendation 13, 'The Commonwealth courts (individually or jointly) should develop a policy on the creation, development, and use of statistical analysis of judicial decision-making'.
Media
- , ABC RN Law Report (2 Aug 2022)
- D. Ghezelbash,Ìý, The Conversation (10 March 2020)
- ÌýABC RN Background Briefing (8 Sep 2019)Ìý
- H. Cohen,Ìý,ÌýABC News, (6 Sep 2019)
- H. Davidson,Ìý, Guardian (22 Sep 2020)
People
Have an inquiry?
For media enquiries, email Kaldor Centre's Communications Officer, Lauren Martin,Ìýlauren.martin@unsw.edu.au.ÌýFor queries relating to interpreting or using the data, or for any suggestions as to other data points that you would like to see collated by the Data Lab, email Associate Professor Daniel Ghezelbash, Kaldor Centre's Deputy Director,Ìýd.ghezelbash@unsw.edu.au.Ìý